What happened
On 6 November 2026 the writer Perumal Murugan wrote that nearly 1,800 books from one publisher he had never heard of, Agal Vilakku, stand on the shelves of Coimbatore's Periyar Arivulagam library, which CM Vijay opened on 16 October; one calls the anthology Naladiyar a poet, a 300-page book is priced ₹1,445 against about ₹350 elsewhere, and he says the books were made with AI under false author names, a charge no inquiry has yet tested. TVK School Education Minister Rajmohan called it corruption under the previous DMK government and announced an inquiry, and the TVK's IT wing posted a purchase-order copy dated 14 February 2026, when the DMK governed; DMK members call that copy fake, and the DMK points to a library stamp of 22 June 2026, under TVK rule, on some of the books. Neither side has published the bill: who paid the publisher, how much, and when.
Checked against sources
- Perumal Murugan's essay (Sindhai, 6 Nov 2026) says nearly 1,800 Agal Vilakku books stand on the library's fourth-floor Tamil shelves, quotes a book that calls Naladiyar 'தமிழின் முக்கியமான கவி மற்றும் தத்துவ ஞானி' (Naladiyar is an anthology of 400 quatrains), and gives ₹1,445 for a 300-page book against ₹350 at other publishers. That he says the books were made with AI under false names and ISBNs is confirmed; whether they were is his charge. sindhai.com
- Minister Rajmohan (TVK, School Education) said about 1,500 Agal Vilakku books were bought in February under the previous DMK government, called it corruption, and said an inquiry had begun. dtnext.in
- Rajmohan also said a contract to buy the books was signed in January. theweek.in
- The TVK IT wing posted a Directorate of Public Libraries order copy to Agal Vilakku, ref. ந.க.எண் 7781/எ1/2025, dated 14.02.2026, when the DMK governed; the reports show no book count, amount or signatory. dailythanthi.com
Show more (12)
- DMK members say the posted order copy is fake, citing no state emblem, letterhead, signature or seal. tamil.oneindia.com
- The DMK IT wing says some Agal Vilakku books carry the library stamp 22.06.2026 (TVK rule) and asks for the order, receipt, inspection and payment dates and the amount paid to each publisher. tamil.webdunia.com
- The DMK says only the Agal Vilakku and Phoenix books carry a June stamp while other publishers' books carry March stamps, and ties the June date to the CM's birthday. dailythanthi.com
- CM Vijay opened the library on 16 Oct 2026; the same day Stalin said, 'Who opens it doesn't matter. Is the act of opening it something to be proud of?' thefederal.com
- On 4 Nov 2026 Stalin said 99.75% of the library's work had been completed under the DMK; that evening in Coimbatore he said 'நல்ல வேளையாக நாம ஒரு 99% பணி முடிச்சுட்டோம்'. dtnext.in
- CM Vijay said the DMK had turned the library into a corruption hub, citing a G.O. of 5 Nov 2025 that set up the book committees, and praised Perumal Murugan. dtnext.in
- Kamal Haasan, a Rajya Sabha MP elected with DMK support, asked that the books be withdrawn from all libraries and burned in the street and the publishers sealed; he named no party. dailythanthi.com
- Perumal Murugan sat on one of about 30 recommending committees and says the committees were not told which books were actually purchased. thehindu.com
- The project was budgeted at ₹300 crore: ₹245 crore for building works, ₹50 crore for books and e-books, ₹5 crore for IT. dtnext.in
- Rajmohan has held School Education, which runs the Directorate of Public Libraries, since May 2026. thenewsminute.com
- As of 6 Nov evening no payment, invoice or amount had been published by either side; Annamalai, the DMK, the CPM and the NTK are asking for the purchase and payment records. thesouthfirst.com
- Congress's Tamil Nadu president Manickam Tagore wrote to CM Vijay for a detailed inquiry, removal of the books, arrests and a check of every library, including the Anna Centenary Library. news7tamil.live
Going round, but unproven
The copy is the TVK IT wing's exhibit; it has not been authenticated, shows no amount or signatory in the reports, and DMK members call it fake. The minister's own account (a January contract, a February purchase) points the same way but is also his claim.
A library stamp records when a book was processed, not when it was ordered or paid for, and the stamp image circulated on X without independent verification. The order and the stamp can both be true: ordered under one government, processed under the next.
This is Perumal Murugan's reading of the texts. The errors he quotes are real, but no inquiry or expert panel has examined the books and the publisher has not been heard.
Show more (6)
₹50 crore is the library's whole books-and-e-books budget, not a measured loss. On the claimed figures the Agal Vilakku copies come to roughly ₹21–25 lakh at printed price if one copy each was bought; the price actually paid is unknown.
Both are allegations. No inquiry finding exists; the inquiry was announced in speech, with no written order, named officer or DVAC case found as of 6 Nov evening, and no payment has been traced to anyone.
He sat on one of about 30 recommending committees and says they were not told what was purchased; nothing shows these titles passed his panel.
The order copy itself cites G.O.(Ms) No. 250 dated 05.12.2025, and the G.O. text has not been published.
No other source, document or photo mentions such an imprint in the library.
His post names neither party: 'இந்தக் காரியத்தை எவர் செய்திருந்தாலும் அவர்கள் தமிழுக்குத் துரோகம் இழைத்தவர்கள்'.
The AI's take
My view, which is opinion: the February order and the June stamp are not rival stories, since the order copy the TVK shows (14 Feb 2026, DMK rule; the DMK calls it fake) and the stamp the DMK shows (22 Jun 2026, TVK rule) can both be true, and a library stamp records when a book was processed, not who bought it or paid for it.
The record that would settle it is the bill (who paid Agal Vilakku, how much and when), and neither side has shown it: the TVK government, which has run the libraries directorate since May, holds the files and can publish it now, and the DMK, which set up the book committees and whose leader claimed 99% of the library's work on 4 Nov, should say whether these titles were on the lists those committees approved.
Until a written inquiry names who chose, priced and paid for these books, 'DMK corruption' and 'a commission under the TVK' remain allegations, and so does Perumal Murugan's AI charge, though the errors he quotes are real.
Why
- The order: the TVK IT wing's copy (ref. 7781/எ1/2025, dated 14.02.2026, from the Directorate of Public Libraries to Agal Vilakku) falls under the DMK government, a month before the poll code. Rajmohan separately speaks of a January contract and a February purchase. But the copy has not been authenticated, the reports show no amount or signatory, and DMK members call it fake because it has no emblem, letterhead, signature or seal.
- The stamp: the DMK points to '22 JUN 2026' on some Agal Vilakku and Phoenix books, against March stamps on other publishers' books. That date falls under the TVK, which has held School Education, and with it the libraries directorate, since 16 May. But an accession stamp marks when the library processed a book, and the image went round on X without independent verification. The order date and the stamp are 128 days apart, and both can be true.
- The committees: both sides agree the book committees were set up under the DMK. Vijay cites the G.O., and the DMK's own post speaks of a writer on its selection committee. Perumal Murugan sat on one of about 30 recommending committees and says they were never told what was bought, so a recommendation is not a purchase; the approved lists would show whether these titles were on them. Stalin's 99.75% (and 99% that evening) was about the library's work, not the books, but it is a claim of ownership of the project.
Show more (2)
- Scale: on the claimed figures the Agal Vilakku copies come to roughly ₹21–25 lakh at printed price if one copy each was bought, about 0.5% of a ₹50 crore books budget, so '₹50 crore scam' mistakes the budget for a loss. The price gap is stark: ₹1,445 printed against ₹350 is about 4.1 times, and about 8 times the state's 2024-25 average of ₹180 a copy. But the price actually paid after the order's negotiated discount is unknown.
- Every charge on both sides is still an allegation. AI writing is Murugan's reading, with no expert panel or publisher reply yet. Nothing has been shown for 'DMK corruption' (Rajmohan, Vijay) or 'a commission under the TVK' (the DMK). The inquiry was announced in speech, and no written order, named officer or DVAC case had been found by 6 Nov evening.
What each side would say back
You treat a copy with no emblem, signature or seal as half the evidence. The June stamp on only these two publishers' books, and the March stamps on the rest, show the purchase went through under the TVK. Our 2024 procurement was transparent, and the TVK held the files for five months and opened the library before raising any of this.
The G.O., the committees, the price talks and the order all came under the DMK; a stamp is only cataloguing. Asking the government that ordered the inquiry to show the bill first puts the burden on those investigating, not on those who chose these books.
You are too even-handed. Books bought at three to four times the price came through the DMK's committees, and every library, the Anna Centenary Library included, should be checked, with arrests, not just a bill.
Show more (3)
A bill is not enough. A special investigation team and a panel of Tamil scholars must vet every book, and the tender and purchase dates must be published; a fake book misleads readers whoever paid for it.
Both must answer, but you stop short. The present government cannot hide behind the old one, and only a judicial inquiry and a special audit that holds officials and suppliers to account will settle it.
Who paid matters less than what is on the shelves. Books that call Naladiyar a poet and invent chief ministers should be pulled now, before anyone cites them.
What would change its mind
If the Directorate authenticates the 14 Feb order and shows the payment was cleared before 10 May, I would put the weight on the DMK-era committees and officials who chose and priced these books. If it shows the books were received, verified and paid for after 16 May, I would say the TVK government shares responsibility for accepting them, whoever ordered them. If the order copy is shown to be forged, the TVK's case falls; if the stamp image is shown to be doctored, the DMK's does. If an expert panel or the ISBN agency finds the books genuine and the price paid near the market, the charge shrinks to a complaint about quality; if a formal inquiry with a written order names who chose, priced and paid, I would follow its findings.
An AI model's take, reviewed for fairness. Not an endorsement.
The research
On 6 Nov 2026 the writer Perumal Murugan published an essay on Sindhai saying that nearly 1,800 books from one publisher he had never heard of, Agal Vilakku, fill the fourth-floor Tamil shelves of Coimbatore's Periyar Arivulagam, which CM Vijay opened on 16 Oct.
He quotes a book that calls the anthology Naladiyar 'தமிழின் முக்கியமான கவி மற்றும் தத்துவ ஞானி' (an important Tamil poet and philosopher), and a 300-page book priced ₹1,445 against about ₹350 at other publishers. He says the books were made with AI under false author names and false ISBNs; that is his charge, which no inquiry has tested, and the publisher has not responded.
The same day TVK School Education Minister Rajmohan called it a DMK-era scam, said about 1,500 books had been bought in February, and announced an inquiry (in speech: no written order, named officer or DVAC case was found by the evening); CM Vijay said the DMK had turned the library into a 'corruption world', citing a G.O. of 5 Nov 2025 that set up the book committees.
The TVK IT wing then posted a Directorate of Public Libraries order copy to Agal Vilakku dated 14.02.2026 (ref.
ந.க.எண் 7781/எ1/2025), a month before the poll code, which DMK members call fake (no emblem, letterhead, signature or seal); the DMK in turn points to a library stamp of 22.06.2026, under TVK rule and on Vijay's birthday, on some Agal Vilakku and Phoenix books, against March stamps on other publishers' books, and asks who got a 'commission' under the TVK.
Both can be true at once: an order under one government and a book processed under the next, since an accession stamp records when the library processed a book, not who bought or paid for it; neither side has published the bill (the payment date, the amount, or who cleared it), which the DMK, Annamalai, the CPM and the NTK all now demand.
On the claimed figures the Agal Vilakku copies come to roughly ₹21–25 lakh at printed price if one copy each was bought (as the order copy says), against a ₹50 crore books budget, so headlines of a '₹50 crore scam' mistake the budget for a loss.
The row turns October's credit fight round: Stalin claimed the library for the DMK on 16 Oct and said on 4 Nov that 99.75% of the work was done under it; two days later the DMK said the disputed books came in under the TVK, while the DMK's former allies, Congress's Manickam Tagore and Kamal Haasan (a Rajya Sabha MP elected with DMK support), asked for action without defending the DMK-era purchase.
Background
The Periyar Arivulagam is a library and science centre at Gandhipuram, Coimbatore, on former Central Prison land: announced in the DMK government's 2024-25 budget, foundation laid by Stalin on 6 Nov 2024, budgeted at ₹300 crore (₹245 crore for the building, ₹50 crore for books and e-books, ₹5 crore for IT), and opened by CM Vijay on 16 Oct 2026 (₹301.71 crore, seven storeys, over one lakh books).
Tamil Nadu's public libraries buy books through the Directorate of Public Libraries under the School Education Department, funded mainly by a library cess on property tax. The DMK's 2024 'transparent' policy moved routine buying to an online portal with ISBN checks, market price comparison and payment after the library verifies the books. For the Periyar library and ten others a separate G.O.
of late 2025 set up five committees to recommend, select, price and approve books. The DMK's Anbil Mahesh ran School Education until May 2026; the TVK took office on 10 May and gave the department to Rajmohan on 16 May. The poll code ran from 15 Mar to the count on 4 May.
Who gains, who loses
Readers lose most: a public library's shelves would carry books that call Naladiyar a poet, invent chief ministers and show a Nandi as a Keezhadi find, and students would cite them. Honest publishers, for whom library orders are a main market, lose orders to imprints nobody can find. Taxpayers paid through the library cess.
For the DMK, its showcase project becomes its liability two days after it was felicitated for it; for the TVK, whose department received, shelved and opened the library, an inquiry that never names who signed and paid would leave the charge unanswered either way.
What most coverage misses
Most coverage set the February order against the June stamp as if only one could be true; both can be, because a stamp marks when the library processed a book, and the record that would settle it, the payment, is in the government's files and has been published by no one.
It missed the scale: on the claimed figures the Agal Vilakku copies are about ₹21–25 lakh at printed price, not the '₹50 crore' of headlines, which is the whole books budget. It missed that recommended is not purchased: Murugan says his committee was never told what was bought.
And it missed that the state's own 2024 rules (an ISBN check, prices compared with the market, payment only after the library verifies the books, penalties for false representation) should have caught such books; whether this purchase went through them is the inquiry's first question.
The numbers
Agal Vilakku books Perumal Murugan counted on the library's fourth-floor Tamil shelves (his count; 'nearly two thousand' on video)
sindhai.comAgal Vilakku books Minister Rajmohan says were bought in February under the DMK (his figure; another report has him at 1,800)
dtnext.inthe printed price of the 300-page Naladiyar book against what other publishers charge for 300 pages (Murugan), about 4.1 times; the price paid after the order's negotiated discount is unknown
sindhai.comthe project as set out in 2024: civil and electrical works, books and e-books, IT
dtnext.inShow more (8)
the cost given at the 16 Oct 2026 opening (seven storeys, 1.98 lakh sq ft, 6.98 acres, 'more than one lakh books')
dtnext.inour arithmetic: 1,500–1,800 copies at about ₹1,400 printed price if one copy of each title was bought, about 0.5% of the ₹50 crore books budget; not a measured loss
sindhai.comour arithmetic: 1,800 books of about 1.25 lakh on the shelves, about 1 book in 70
thefederal.comfrom the date on the order copy the TVK shows (DMK rule) to the stamp the DMK shows (TVK rule); both can hold at once
dailythanthi.comthe share of the library's work Stalin said was completed under the DMK (4 Nov 2026); '99%' in his speech that evening
dtnext.inthe state's 2024-25 library buying under the transparent policy (6,416 titles, 3,873 libraries), about ₹180 a copy (our arithmetic)
dinakaran.comthe TVK's 2026-27 budget line to redesign all public libraries into digital libraries, against ₹50 crore for one library's books
oneindia.comTimeline
- School Education Minister Anbil Mahesh (DMK) unveils the 'Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024' for the state's public libraries: ISBN required, prices compared with the market, a price negotiation committee, conflict-of-interest rules. dtnext.in
- The School Education Department sets out the Coimbatore library and science centre: ₹300 crore, of which ₹245 crore civil and electrical works, ₹50 crore books and e-books, ₹5 crore IT. dtnext.in
- CM M.K. Stalin lays the foundation stone and names the library after Periyar, on former Central Prison land in Coimbatore (6.98 acres). dtnext.in
- A G.O. (as reported) sets up five committees (recommendation, selection, high-level, price negotiation, technical) to buy books and e-books for five special libraries, the Periyar Arivulagam among them, and six new district central libraries. The order copy the TVK posted cites G.O.(Ms) No. 250 dated 05.12.2025: the date is not settled. dinamalar.com
- IANS reports the library 'set for February opening', with ₹50 crore for book procurement and over 1.2 lakh books planned. socialnews.xyz
- A purchase order to Phoenix Publications, ref. 7781/எ1/2025, dated 13 Feb 2026, according to the order copies the TVK IT wing released on 6 Nov (not authenticated). dinamalar.com
Show more (16)
- A purchase order from the Directorate of Public Libraries to Agal Vilakku, ref. ந.க.எண் 7781/எ1/2025, dated 14.02.2026 (DMK government), according to the copy the TVK IT wing posted on 6 Nov; DMK members call the copy fake. dailythanthi.com
- The ECI announces the Tamil Nadu poll and the Model Code of Conduct takes effect (polling 23 Apr, counting 4 May). thenewsminute.com
- Viduthalai, the daily Periyar founded, writes that the transparent procurement system has stopped substandard books from entering libraries. viduthalai.in
- C. Joseph Vijay is sworn in as Chief Minister; the TVK forms the government. onmanorama.com
- Rajmohan (TVK) is given School Education, Tamil Development and Information; the Directorate of Public Libraries sits under School Education. thenewsminute.com
- The Periyar Arivulagam library stamp '22 JUN 2026' on some Agal Vilakku (and Phoenix) books, according to the DMK IT wing; other publishers' books carry March stamps (DMK's claim; the stamp image circulated on X, provenance not independently verified). 22 June is Vijay's birthday. tamil.oneindia.com
- CM Vijay inaugurates the Periyar Arivulagam (₹301.71 crore, seven storeys, 1.98 lakh sq ft, 'more than one lakh books'); Minister Rajmohan is among the ministers present. dtnext.in
- Stalin claims the project for the DMK: 'Who opens it doesn't matter. Is the act of opening it something to be proud of?' thefederal.com
- Stalin visits the library with DK president K. Veeramani and says 99.75% of the work was completed under the DMK; that evening, at the DK's felicitation at the V.O.C. Ground, Coimbatore, he says 'நல்ல வேளையாக நாம ஒரு 99% பணி முடிச்சுட்டோம்'. dtnext.in
- Perumal Murugan's essay 'பெரியார் அறிவுலகத்தில் பெரிய ஊழல்' appears on Sindhai: about 1,800 Agal Vilakku books, the Naladiyar 'poet', ₹1,445 for 300 pages, and his charge of AI-made books with false authors and ISBNs. sindhai.com
- Minister Rajmohan blames the previous DMK government, says about 1,500 books were bought in February, and announces an inquiry. dtnext.in
- CM Vijay says the DMK has turned the library into a corruption hub, cites the G.O. of 5 Nov 2025 and praises Perumal Murugan, who he says sat on a recommending committee. dtnext.in
- Kamal Haasan asks that the fake books be withdrawn from all libraries and burned in the street and the publishers sealed; he names no party. dailythanthi.com
- The DMK says only the Agal Vilakku and Phoenix books carry a June stamp, ties the date to the CM's birthday, and asks who got a commission under the TVK. dailythanthi.com
- TNCC president Manickam Tagore writes to CM Vijay for a detailed inquiry, removal of the books, arrests and a check of every library including the Anna Centenary Library. news7tamil.live
- DMK members call the TVK's posted order copy fake, saying it lacks the state emblem, letterhead, signature and seal. tamil.oneindia.com
Claims checked
It is Murugan's reading of the texts ('செய்யறிவு மூலம் நூல்கள் உருவாக்கப்பட்டுள்ளன'). The errors he quotes are on the page, but no inquiry or expert panel has examined the books and the publisher has not been heard. sindhai.com
The copy has not been authenticated and shows no amount or signatory in the reports; DMK members call it fake. Rajmohan separately says the contract was signed in January and the books bought in February, and the DMK does not deny that the G.O. and committees were set up under it. dailythanthi.com
A library accession stamp records when a book was processed, not when it was ordered or paid for; the stamp image's provenance is not independently verified. It may show the books were received under the TVK, but the purchase decision and payment dates are not public. tamil.webdunia.com
₹50 crore is the whole books-and-e-books budget, not a measured loss. On the claimed figures the Agal Vilakku copies come to about ₹21–25 lakh at printed price if one copy each was bought; larger sums would need more copies or the other libraries under the same G.O., which no one has counted. dtnext.in
Show more (9)
His full post names neither the DMK nor the TVK: 'இந்தக் காரியத்தை எவர் செய்திருந்தாலும் அவர்கள் தமிழுக்குத் துரோகம் இழைத்தவர்கள்'. dailythanthi.com
He sat on one recommending committee (modern literature and criticism) of about 30, and says the committees were not told what was purchased. Nothing shows these titles passed his panel. thehindu.com
At the library he said 99.75% (DT Next/PTI, ETV Bharat); that evening at the V.O.C. Ground felicitation: 'நல்ல வேளையாக நாம ஒரு 99% பணி முடிச்சுட்டோம்'. He spoke of the library's work, not of the book purchase. dtnext.in
Asked as a question; no payment, recipient or amount has been shown. dailythanthi.com
An allegation. The inquiry was announced in speech; no G.O., named officer, DVAC case or finding exists yet, and the order copy it rests on is disputed. dtnext.in
The order copy the TVK posted cites G.O.(Ms) No. 250 dated 05.12.2025; Rajmohan was heard citing proceedings of 18.11.2025. The G.O. text has not been published. dtnext.in
The order copy is dated 14 Feb, a month before the code (15 Mar); the stamp is June, after the new government took office. Delivery might have fallen in the code period, but nothing shows it. tamil.oneindia.com
No other source, document or photo mentions such an imprint in the library. vikatan.com
Neither figure has an official source; an isbn.gov.in lookup and the Directorate's order list would settle them.
Findings
His essay, word for word: 'அகல்விளக்கு பதிப்பகம்' வெளியிட்ட கிட்டத்தட்ட 1,800 நூல்கள் (ஆம், மெனக்கெட்டு எண்ணிப் பார்த்தோம்) அலமாரிகளை அலங்கரிக்கின்றன'; the book says 'நாலடியார், தமிழின் முக்கியமான கவி மற்றும் தத்துவ ஞானி'; 'முந்நூறு பக்க நூலின் விலை ரூ.1445/- மட்டும்தான்!'; 'பிற பதிப்பகங்கள் எல்லாம் முந்நூறு பக்க நூலுக்கு முந்நூற்று ஐம்பது ரூபாய்தான் விலை வைக்கிறார்கள்'. Naladiyar is an anthology of 400 quatrains, not a person. On video he said 'nearly two thousand' and about ₹1,500; the essay's figures are used here. That he wrote it is confirmed; the count is his. Sindhai (Perumal Murugan's essay), 2026-11-06
'தொழில்நுட்பம் மேம்படாத செய்யறிவு மூலம் நூல்கள் உருவாக்கப்பட்டுள்ளன. நூலாசிரியர் பெயர்கள் எல்லாம் பொய்ப்பெயர்கள். நூல்களில் காணப்படும் ... (ISBN) அனைத்தும் பொய்யானவை'; 'அது கோடிக்கணக்கில் இருக்கும் என்றும் தோன்றுகிறது'. He also cites a Keezhadi book showing a Nandi as a Keezhadi find and a book naming invented chief ministers. He blames no party. These are his readings; no inquiry, ISBN-agency check or publisher's reply has tested them. Sindhai (Perumal Murugan's essay), 2026-11-06
DT Next: around 1,500 books 'had been purchased in February under the previous DMK regime'; 'The inquiry into this corruption has begun. Whoever is involved will be brought before the law.' The Week has him saying a contract was signed in January. Pass 1 found no G.O., named officer or DVAC case for the inquiry by 6 Nov evening, so it rests on his words. DT Next, 2026-11-06
Daily Thanthi reports the post and the reference. The image itself (pass 1) orders one copy of each listed title, Tamil and English, at a price fixed after discount by the price negotiation committee, delivered within seven days; it names no book count, amount or signatory in the reports. 14 Feb 2026 was under the DMK government, a month before the poll code. The document is the TVK's exhibit and has not been authenticated. Daily Thanthi, 2026-11-06
Show more (23)
Oneindia Tamil: 'இந்த நகல் போலியானது என்று திமுகவினர் குற்றம்சாட்டியுள்ளனர்', citing no state emblem, letterhead, signature or seal. A DMK-side reply on Instagram also says the date was corrected by hand (a private account; a lead only). The DMK did not deny that the G.O. and its committees were set up under its government. Oneindia Tamil, 2026-11-06
DMK IT wing statement: '22.06.2026 – அகல்விளக்கு பதிப்பகத்தின் சில புத்தகங்களில் பெரியார் அறிவுலகத்தின் முத்திரைத் தேதி'; 'ஒவ்வொரு பதிப்பகத்திற்கும் வழங்கப்பட்ட தொகை மற்றும் ஆன்லைன் பரிவர்த்தனை விவரங்களை ஏன் வெளியிடக்கூடாது?'. The stamp image (accession no. 048483) circulated on X; its provenance was not independently verified. Webdunia Tamil, 2026-11-06
@arivalayam post, as reported: 'அகல் விளக்கு மற்றும் பீனிக்ஸ் பதிப்பகத்தின் போலியான நூல்களில் மட்டும் ஜூன் மாதம் என்று முத்திரை இடப்பட்டுள்ளது ... அந்த தேதி கூட dummy CMன் பிறந்தநாள் தான்'; other publishers' books such as வால்காவிலிருந்து கங்கை வரை carry 'திமுக ஆட்சியின் மார்ச் மாத முத்திரை'; 'தவெக ஆட்சியில் யாருக்கு கமிஷன் போனது?'. The commission line is an allegation with nothing shown. Daily Thanthi, 2026-11-06
The fresh verifier searched in Tamil and English and found no published bill; the DMK asks for payment dates and amounts, Annamalai for purchase orders and invoices (The South First), the CPM for tender and purchase dates, and Seeman for supply orders, prices and payments. On camera (Thanthi TV, machine transcript) Rajmohan said lakhs had already been settled with some payment still pending ('பல லட்ச ரூபா already settlement ... payment பாக்கி'), which would mean the government holds the payment record; he gave no amount or date. The South First, 2026-11-06
Inference, our arithmetic: 1,500–1,800 copies × about ₹1,400 printed price, if one copy of each title was bought as the order copy says; the price actually paid after the negotiated discount is unknown. The ₹50 crore is the books-and-e-books line of the ₹300 crore project (DT Next 2024). 'Crores' (Murugan, and Rajmohan as quoted by Dinamalar) would need more copies, more titles, the Phoenix books or the ten other libraries under the same G.O., none of which has been counted. DT Next, 2024-10-14
DT Next/PTI: 'Fortunately, 99.75 per cent of the work on Periyar Arivulagam had been completed during the DMK regime'; 'Had it been left halfway, it would not have been surprising if the present government had shut it down.' At the DK felicitation at the V.O.C. Ground that evening (Kalaignar TV upload, 12:43, YouTube Tamil captions): 'நல்ல வேளையாக நாம ஒரு 99% பணி முடிச்சுட்டோம்'. His words were about the library's construction and completion, not the book purchase. DT Next (PTI), 2026-11-04
Stalin, 16 Oct: 'Who opens it doesn't matter. Is the act of opening it something to be proud of?' (The Federal). His full statement (Hindu Tamil): 'திமுகவால் கட்டியெழுப்பப்பட்டவை. வேறு எந்த அரசும் செய்யாதவை.' The TVK's reply the same day (Aadhav Arjuna, Kumudam): opened for public use as a continuing scheme; Vijay has no need to seek fame from it. The verifier found no October statement in which the TVK called the library its own. The Federal, 2026-10-16
Vijay (DT Next): the G.O. of 5.11.2025 set up the committees and Murugan was on the modern-literature panel; he 'hailed' him. The DMK's post also speaks of 'திமுக ஆட்சியில் புத்தகத் தேர்வுக்குழுவில் இருந்த எழுத்தாளர் ஒருவர்'. The Hindu quotes Murugan: 'I do not know whether those books were actually purchased, as we were not informed about the purchases', and he did not know when the books were bought. Nothing shows these titles passed his panel: recommended is not purchased. The Hindu, 2026-11-06
His post, as reported: 'தி.மு.க. கொஞ்சம் வித்தியாசமாக ஊழல் செய்து, கோவை பெரியார் அறிவுலகத்தையே ஊழல் உலகமாக மாற்றியிருக்கிறது. ஊழல் இலக்கியம் படைப்பதில் தி.மு.க. உயர் ரகம்தான்'. The DMK says this was his first post since 9 Oct. His allegation of DMK corruption is a claim; no finding exists. DT Next, 2026-11-06
His X post: 'இந்தப் போலி நூல்கள், அனைத்து நூலகங்களிலிருந்தும் உடனடியாகத் திரும்பப் பெறப்பட்டு வீதியில் கொட்டி எரிக்கப்பட வேண்டும். மோசடி செய்த பதிப்பகங்கள் சீல் வைக்கப்பட வேண்டும்'; 'இந்தக் காரியத்தை எவர் செய்திருந்தாலும் அவர்கள் தமிழுக்குத் துரோகம் இழைத்தவர்கள்'. Same words in Minnambalam and Webdunia. He was elected unopposed to the Rajya Sabha on 12 Jun 2025 with DMK support (ETV Bharat). A search summary saying he 'blamed the DMK' is wrong. Daily Thanthi, 2026-11-06
TNCC president Manickam Tagore's letter: praise for an 'ஊழலற்ற, நேர்மையான, சிறப்பான ஆட்சி'; arrest those who bought AI-made fake books 'மூன்று நான்கு மடங்கு அதிக விலை கொடுத்து'; vet all books; check the Anna Centenary Library; 'திமுக, திராவிடம் பேசுவதே கொள்ளையடிப்பதற்காகத் தான்' (his allegation). News7 Tamil, 2026-11-06
'முந்தைய திமுகவின் ஆட்சியில் தொடங்கப்பட்ட திட்டம் என்பதைக் கூறி, இன்றைய அரசு தன்னுடையப் பொறுப்பிலிருந்து விலக முடியாது. அதேபோல, திட்டத்தை உருவாக்கிய பெருமையை உரிமைகோரும் முந்தைய திமுகவின் ஆட்சியாளர்களும், கொள்முதல் குறித்த கேள்விகளுக்கு விளக்கமளிக்க முன்வர வேண்டும்.' He asks for the committee details, supply orders, prices and payments, a judicial inquiry and a special audit. Annamalai (We the Leaders) asks for the purchase orders, invoices, delivery records and verification report. Minnambalam, 2026-11-06
CPM state secretary P. Shanmugam: SIT, committee details, tender and purchase dates, scholars' panel (DT Next). Su. Venkatesan: a fake book 'நிலைத்திருந்து நிரந்தரமாக நஞ்சூட்டும்'; 'போலியான புத்தகங்கள் பெரியார் அறிவுலகத்திலிருந்து உடனே அகற்றப்பட வேண்டும்!'. PMK's Anbumani asked for a DVAC probe and a commission of inquiry. DT Next, 2026-11-06
The procurement portal's guidelines (read 6 Nov): every book needs an ISBN; price negotiation 'overseen by the Procurement Price Negotiation Committee'; 'Book prices are compared to similar books in the market'; an order not supplied in 30 days is cancelled; payment '10 days, after verification of the received book by the respective libraries'; false representation is penalised. The Periyar books came under a separate G.O. with its own committees. If the general rule applied, verification and payment for books stamped in June would fall in the TVK's months: an inference. Tamil Nadu Public Libraries book procurement portal
Dinamalar lists the five committees and the libraries: Coimbatore Periyar, Trichy Kamarajar, Salem Bharathidasan, Cuddalore Anjalai Ammal, Tirunelveli Quaid-e-Millath, and six new district central libraries. Its date is reported as 5 Nov 2025 (Vijay, Dinamalar); the order copy cites G.O.(Ms) No. 250 dated 05.12.2025; the G.O. text was not found. Dinamalar, 2026-11-06
The News Minute's portfolio list (School Education, Tamil Development, Information and Publicity); DT Next lists him among the ministers at the 16 Oct opening. That the June stamp marks receipt under his department is an inference from the DMK's exhibit. The News Minute, 2026-05-16
Vikatan quoted the essay's early line on the Madipakkam address and Google Maps (later removed from the live essay); the TVK's order image shows '92, கொடவாசல்'. Reporters found a building with no signboard and could not reach anyone (TOI reporter's post). Rajmohan's 'அகல்விளக்கு என்ற பதிப்பகம் செவ்வாய் கிரகத்திலேயே இல்லை' is rhetoric: it exists at least as an address and an imprint. Vikatan, 2026-11-06
₹1,445 ÷ ₹350 ≈ 4.1 (Murugan's figures). Dinakaran (15 May 2025): the transparent policy bought 22,17,379 copies of 6,416 titles for ₹40 crore for 3,873 libraries, about ₹180 a copy (our arithmetic); ₹1,445 ÷ ₹180 ≈ 8. The printed price is not the price paid, which the order says was discounted. Dinakaran, 2025-05-15
Inference from the two exhibits (Daily Thanthi; Webdunia) and the absence of any bill. Ordered on 14 Feb and stamped on 22 Jun is 128 days. Viewers' top question across news videos is 'who bought it, DMK or TVK, and when?' (pass 3). The government in office holds the Directorate's files; the DMK set up the committees. Oneindia Tamil, 2026-11-06
Rajmohan said the file would go to the CM and that libraries opening soon would be checked. Minnambalam's report of a new case is unconfirmed. Anbil Mahesh ran School Education until May 2026; Minister Arunraaj alleges the committee worked under him (his allegation). Minnambalam, 2026-11-06
His post lists 'அகல் விளக்குப் பதிப்பகம், உதயசூரியன் பதிப்பகம், பீனிக்ஸ் பதிப்பகம்' and calls it 'Party Fund'. No other source mentions an Udhayasuriyan imprint in the library. Vikatan, 2026-11-06
404 Media found AI-generated books on Hoopla, which libraries pay per borrow; Hoopla said it would remove them. The Register (22 Sep 2023): Amazon KDP's limit 'to help protect against abuse'. A different system: Tamil Nadu buys physical copies by order. 404 Media
'இந்த வெளிப்படையான கொள்முதல் முறை மூலம் தரமற்ற புத்தகங்கள் நுழைவது தடுக்கப்பட்டுள்ளது' (27 Mar 2026). The same piece says that in the past selections were kept secret and a few publishers favoured on 'commission' (a partisan claim, no case named). Viduthalai, 2026-03-27
What they said before
Unveiled a 'transparent' book procurement policy for all public libraries: ISBN required, prices compared with the market, conflict-of-interest rules and a genre price index. dtnext.in
Formed an expert book selection committee 'for transparency', with invoices and prices to be cross-checked against purchase orders. dtnext.in
Revised library purchase rates for the first time since 2009 after publishers refused to supply at the old rates. dtnext.in
Show more (8)
Said the DMK's transparent procurement had stopped substandard books from entering libraries. viduthalai.in
Said the library would be completed within three months and that under this government contractors are not pressed to pay commission to the CM and ministers. dtnext.in
Claimed the library for the DMK on opening day: 'Who opens it doesn't matter. Is the act of opening it something to be proud of?' thefederal.com
Full statement: the library, 'ஒரு லட்சத்து 25 ஆயிரம் நூல்களைக் கொண்ட' knowledge mine, and the state's libraries are 'திமுகவால் கட்டியெழுப்பப்பட்டவை. வேறு எந்த அரசும் செய்யாதவை'; he had said in February not to rush the opening. hindutamil.in
Replied that the TVK government opened the library for public use as a continuing government scheme and that Vijay has no need to seek fame from it. kumudam.com
Said in a video that he refused a ₹5 crore offer for a cultural body's post, naming no offerer; the DMK then asked the DVAC to register a case on his claim. dtnext.in
Said 99.75% of the work was completed under the DMK and that the present government might otherwise have shut it down. dtnext.in
The TVK's first budget set ₹10 crore to redesign public libraries into digital libraries. oneindia.com
Still open
- When was Agal Vilakku paid, how much, and who cleared the payment: before the code (15 Mar), during it, or after the TVK took office (10 May)?
- Is the 14 Feb 2026 order copy genuine? Will the Directorate publish the signed order with its value and signatory?
- When were the books delivered and verified by the library, and why the gap from an order with a seven-day delivery condition to a June stamp?
Show more (7)
- Were these titles on the lists the recommendation, selection and high-level committees approved, or added later? Who sat on the price negotiation committee (by role)?
- Is the G.O. dated 5 Nov or 5 Dec 2025 (G.O.(Ms) No. 250), and will its text be published?
- How many titles and copies were bought from Agal Vilakku and Phoenix, and are the same books in the ten other libraries under the same G.O.?
- Is there a formal inquiry (a G.O., a named officer, a DVAC case), and will its findings be made public?
- Are the books' ISBNs genuine on isbn.gov.in, and who runs Agal Vilakku and Phoenix?
- Did this purchase follow the 2024 procurement rules (market price check, 30-day supply, payment after library verification)?
- Will the disputed books be taken off the shelves, as Murugan, Kamal Haasan, Su. Venkatesan and the CPM ask?
Sources · 42
- sindhai.com
- dtnext.in
- theweek.in
- dailythanthi.com
- tamil.oneindia.com
- tamil.webdunia.com
- dailythanthi.com
- thefederal.com
Show more (34)
- dtnext.in
- dtnext.in
- dailythanthi.com
- thehindu.com
- dtnext.in
- thenewsminute.com
- thesouthfirst.com
- news7tamil.live
- Minnambalam · minnambalam.com
- DT Next · dtnext.in
- Tamil Nadu Public Libraries book procurement portal · bookprocurement.tamilnadupubliclibraries.org
- Dinamalar · dinamalar.com
- Vikatan · vikatan.com
- Dinakaran · dinakaran.com
- Oneindia Tamil · tamil.oneindia.com
- Minnambalam · minnambalam.com
- Vikatan · vikatan.com
- 404 Media · 404media.co
- Viduthalai · viduthalai.in
- dtnext.in
- dtnext.in
- socialnews.xyz
- dinamalar.com
- thenewsminute.com
- onmanorama.com
- dtnext.in
- oneindia.com
- dtnext.in
- tamil.oneindia.com
- dtnext.in
- dtnext.in
- hindutamil.in
- kumudam.com
- dtnext.in